As one that cherishes the ideals of a free and democratic society, the recent decision by the Department of Homeland Security to revoke the work permit of Professor Tariq Ramadan is extremely troubling. Dr. Ramadan was appointed the Luce professor of religion, conflict and peace building at the Joan B. Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies at the University of Notre Dame in Indiana. He accepted the position expecting to start his tenure on Aug. 24 of this year. In late July, however, the department informed Ramadan that his approved visa was denied. No explanation for the denial was issued to either him or the university.
Ramadan is a renowned academic and leading Islamic thinker in Europe. His work has spurred a creative debate among many European Muslims concerning the new challenges of the 21st century. His writings, calling for a more critical analysis of the identity of the western Muslim and of the relationship that exists between Islam and the West, have encouraged much self-reflection among European Muslims.
Our government's denial of Ramadan's appointment to the Kroc Institute emboldens those who deny the beauty of democracy. This constitutes an unacceptable decision because an open and free society cannot function without a vibrant and diverse national discourse concerning the current issues facing our nation and the global society in which we are a part. The United States is struggling against extremism and is looking for moderates to help facilitate a more peaceful global order. Ramadan is one of those moderates. He has questioned and contributed to creating more understanding between Islam and the West and has gained much respect from academics and scholars from all over the world for his
courageous efforts.
Recently, the American Association of University Professors issued an open letter to Secretary of State Colin Powell and Secretary of Homeland Security Tom Ridge that included the statement, Foreign scholars offered appointments at an American institution of higher learning should not be barred by our government from entering the United States because of their political beliefs or associations or writings. Assuming that the work visa issued to Ramadan was withdrawn for the reason stated by the Department of Homeland Security
then the action was manifestly at odds with our society's respect for academic freedom.
This is not a matter of national security, as Ramadan poses no threat to our nation. Rather, it is a matter that highlights the incredible need for a more candid and open discussion about the current crises plaguing our world. The smear campaigns launched by right-wing activists, who are, in many instances, ardent supporters of Israel's illegal practices, against academics they disagree with, only hinder societal and global progression. They contribute to increased mistrust and enmity between our nation and the Muslim world. I call on all professors and students to defend those who dissent because if the noble practice of academic freedom ends, Americans can no longer boast the pride of living in a nation of freedom and justice for all.
-Jordan Robinson writes for the state staff. Send him an e-mail at jr197103@ohiou.edu. 17
Archives
The Post Editorial Board
