Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
The Post - Athens, OH
The independent newspaper covering campus and community since 1911.
The Post


Court rejects former OU student's appeal for new trial

A former Ohio University student could spend three years in prison after an appeals court denied his case yesterday.

Matthew C. Kulchar, 23, was convicted of tampering with evidence at a trial in October 2009. He was found not guilty of rape and kidnapping.

OU police officers arrested Kulchar, saying he held another OU student in her Boyd Hall room and raped her for several hours.

While police were holding Kulchar, he sent a text message to his roommate asking him to dispose of the Spongebob Squarepants boxers he wore during the sexual encounter.

Kulchar said the sex was consensual, and the jury found him not guilty of rape and kidnapping. He was sentenced to three years in prison for the charge of tampering with evidence. He was allowed to remain out on bail until his appeal — which he filed Jan. 26, 2010 — was finalized.

In his appeal, Kulchar said he did not know he was being investigated when he sent the message because the police did not define “investigation” for him.  He also said he was convicted by insufficient evidence, according to court documents.

Kulchar asked for a new trial, saying he could not be charged or convicted of tampering with evidence because he was being investigated for a crime he did not commit.


Thursday, the court filed its decision to overrule Kulchar’s appeal, stating that he was sentenced lawfully and police had sufficient evidence.

Disposing of the underwear warranted a charge of tampering with evidence because Kulchar did “impair its value or availability as evidence.” The court did not need to have the underwear as evidence because investigators had the text messages from Kulchar’s cellphone.

Kulchar’s three-year prison sentence will not be imposed for another 60 days to give him time to bring the case before the Ohio Supreme Court, according to court documents.

Powered by SNworks Solutions by The State News
All Content © 2016-2024 The Post, Athens OH