The holiday season calls for music played at any possible moment. With holiday music being played as early as Nov. 1 on the radio, in the stores and at parties, classics like “All I Want for Christmas Is You” and “Jingle Bell Rock” can get old.

To fix the yearly problem of overplayed holiday music, listen to these 25 lesser known songs to jam to and add to any holiday or party playlist. Chances are, they will be new favorites.

It might be surprising to see the likes of Jimmy Buffett and the Barenaked Ladies on the list, but your loved ones are sure to enjoy these under-the-radar hits at your next holiday gathering. Check out the link below to see what made it.